On November 16, 2026, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) released the Comprehensive Regulations to Uncover Suspicious Healthcare (CRUSH) proposed rule, CMS-6098-P. It is a standalone program-integrity rule that reaches Medicare, Medicare Advantage (MA), Part D, Medicaid, CHIP and the Health Insurance Marketplace at once. It is a proposal, not a final rule: nothing in it takes effect until CMS reviews comments and publishes a final version.
Key Takeaways
- CRUSH is proposed, not final. The Federal Register is scheduled to publish it on November 19, 2026, and CMS’s press release puts the comment deadline at January 19, 2027.
- For MA plans, the largest financial item is risk adjustment data validation (RADV): CMS would extrapolate audit findings starting with payment year 2018 audits and would not apply a fee-for-service (FFS) adjuster.
- Providers billing MA plans would need approved Original Medicare enrollment, starting with the first plan year that begins two years after a final rule.
- State Medicaid agencies would take on federally overseen eligibility audits, new reporting duties and a 60-day overpayment return rule while they are also building work-requirement systems.
- CMS projects “nearly $90 billion” in federal savings from 2027 through 2036. That is a CMS projection, not a measured result.
What is the CRUSH proposed rule, and where does it stand?
CRUSH is a discretionary rule, separate from the annual Medicare payment rules, and CMS says it “intends to conduct program integrity rulemaking of this kind on an annual basis going forward,” according to the CMS fact sheet on CMS-6098-P. That makes CRUSH the first of an expected series, not a one-off.
The dates below are separate, and they are easy to blur:
| Milestone | Date | Source and status |
|---|---|---|
| Announcement | November 16, 2026 | CMS press release and fact sheet |
| Federal Register publication | November 19, 2026 (scheduled) | Public inspection document 2026-23461 |
| Comment deadline | January 19, 2027 | CMS press release; the rule text sets it at 60 days after publication |
| Effective dates | Not yet set | Set only in a final rule; one MA provision has a stated delay (see below) |
Comments go through docket CMS-2026-0826 on Regulations.gov, according to the public inspection copy of the proposed rule. The rule follows a February 27, 2026, request for information that drew more than 560 comments, some of which CMS says shaped the proposal.
CMS Administrator Dr. Mehmet Oz framed the rule this way in the CMS press release: “Every taxpayer dollar lost to fraud is a dollar that cannot support the care these programs were created to provide.”
Medicare Advantage and Part D: the provisions with the most financial weight
For MA organizations, three CRUSH provisions matter most: RADV extrapolation, mandatory fraud reporting and the Original Medicare enrollment requirement for network providers.
RADV extrapolation from payment year 2018
CMS would write three RADV positions into regulation, according to the fact sheet. It would not apply an FFS adjuster, it would set the sampling methodology in rule text, and it would extrapolate audit findings beginning with payment year 2018 audits. Extrapolation means an error rate found in a sample of enrollee records is applied across the whole contract, so a plan’s repayment exposure scales with contract size rather than with the records reviewed. CMS would also replace sub-regulatory guidance on hardship exceptions for medical record submission with a formal regulatory framework.
$9 billion versus $21 billion: two different numbers
Two RADV-related figures circulate with this rule, and they measure different things:
- About $21 billion per year is the rule’s own description of the problem: MA overpayments “due to the improper inflation of beneficiary risk scores,” per the Federal Register document.
- About $9 billion per payment year is CMS’s estimate of the average MA overpayments it expects to collect through RADV under the proposal, per the fact sheet.
The first number estimates overpayments; the second estimates recoveries. A third figure is also in the news: CMS’s FY2026 improper payments fact sheet puts the Part C improper payment rate at 5.68%, or $23.86 billion, down from 6.09% the year before. CMS states that improper payment rates “do not measure fraud,” and it names MA documentation that does not support submitted diagnoses as the main Part C driver. Coverage that treats the three numbers as one figure will mislead readers.
Mandatory fraud, waste and abuse reporting
Today, MA organizations and Part D sponsors report fraud, waste and abuse referrals voluntarily. CRUSH would make reporting of substantiated or suspicious referrals mandatory. CMS says only 46% of Part C and D contracts reported referrals voluntarily for calendar year 2025. Reporting of payment suspensions based on credible allegations of fraud would expand from pharmacies to all provider and supplier types; only 19% of contracts reported such suspensions in 2025, per the fact sheet.
Original Medicare enrollment for providers billing MA
Under proposed § 422.222(a), eligible providers and suppliers billing MA would need approved Original Medicare enrollment, so that CMS screening applies before they join MA networks. The requirement would not apply to PACE plans. If finalized, it would take effect on the first day of the plan year that begins two years after the final rule is published. For a sense of how MA and Original Medicare differ for enrollees, see our guide to Medicare Advantage vs Original Medicare in 2027.
What changes for all Medicare providers and suppliers?
Every Medicare-enrolled provider and supplier would report any enrollment change within 30 calendar days. Today, critical changes carry a 30-day window and other changes 90 days. CMS could also deny or revoke enrollment when a domestic or foreign owner, managing employee, officer or director cannot be identified, or poses an undue risk of fraud, waste and abuse.
Durable medical equipment suppliers face added rules: CMS could refuse surety bonds from sureties that failed past obligations, and suppliers would disclose associated entities that provide marketing, fulfillment, wholesale or device manufacturing services. The existing ban on unsolicited telephone contact with beneficiaries would extend to text messages, and a new provision would cover social media direct messages, email without an opt-out and door-to-door solicitation.
Medicaid and CHIP: new audit exposure for states
For state Medicaid agencies, CRUSH changes how eligibility accuracy is audited and how fraud information moves between agencies. The main proposals, per the fact sheet:
- Eligibility audits. The Medicaid Eligibility Quality Control (MEQC) program would be replaced by federally overseen beneficiary eligibility audits under Social Security Act § 1903(u). Disallowances would be based on audit error rates above the statute’s 3% threshold, and states would need to show specific corrective actions to demonstrate good faith.
- Fraud determinations. For payment suspensions under 42 C.F.R. § 455.23, states could rely on a credible allegation of fraud determination made by CMS or another federal agency.
- Good cause exception. The “good cause” exception to payment suspension would be narrowed.
- Fraud reports. State fraud and abuse reports would add data such as NPI, address and actions taken against the provider.
- Electronic visit verification (EVV). States would use EVV data in prepayment review and preliminary investigations for personal care and home health services.
- Provider identifiers. States would collect and use individual National Provider Identifiers (NPIs) for all eligible provider types.
- Monthly reporting. States would submit monthly reports of denied or terminated providers.
- Enrollment and disclosure. Grounds for denying or terminating Medicaid enrollment would mirror Medicare’s, and providers would disclose more about owners, managing employees and adverse legal actions.
- PERM corrective actions. CMS would approve corrective action plans and require a single combined Medicaid and CHIP plan.
- Overpayments. Self-identified Medicaid fee-for-service overpayments would be reported and returned within 60 calendar days. Managed care plans would report enrollee deaths and address changes within 30 days and return related overpayments.
- Request for information. CMS asks how to ensure practitioner payroll deductions, including union dues, occur only with voluntary consent.
The timing matters. States are building verification systems for Medicaid community engagement requirements that start January 1, 2027, as covered in our explainer on Medicaid work requirements in 2027. CMS’s November 13 letter to state Medicaid directors says determinations made under an approved mitigation plan during the optional hold-harmless period, which runs through June 30, 2027, will not count as errors for PERM, MEQC or other audits. CRUSH would retire MEQC and add a new federal audit program. States should ask CMS, in comments, whether that protection carries into the new eligibility audits.
Marketplace agents and brokers
CRUSH would bar agents, brokers and web-brokers with certain felony convictions or past fraud-related adverse actions. CMS could suspend an agreement on “a credible allegation of abusive conduct” that may harm consumers, replacing the current “reasonable suspicion of fraud” standard, and the broker would have 30 calendar days to refute it. Terminations for cause would use a preponderance-of-the-evidence standard, and access to Marketplace systems from outside the United States, including through a VPN that routes traffic abroad, would be blocked. Brokers active in the current enrollment season can find dates in our ACA Marketplace open enrollment 2027 guide.
Readiness by role: what is proposed now and what could wait
The table below is US Health Insights’ operational analysis of the CMS fact sheet. Only one provision has a stated effective date; the others would be set in a final rule.
| Role | Proposed change to watch | Timing if finalized | Before January 19, 2027 |
|---|---|---|---|
| MA organization | RADV extrapolation from PY2018 audits; no FFS adjuster | Would cover PY2018 and later audits; effective date set in final rule | Model contract-level exposure; review sampling methodology in the rule text |
| MA organization and Part D sponsor | Mandatory fraud referral and payment suspension reporting | Set in final rule | Map current special investigations unit reporting against the proposal |
| Provider group in MA networks | Approved Original Medicare enrollment required | First plan year beginning two years after the final rule | Inventory network providers not enrolled in Original Medicare |
| Any Medicare provider or supplier | 30-day reporting of all enrollment changes; ownership identification | Set in final rule | Assign an owner for enrollment updates and ownership records |
| State Medicaid agency | Federal eligibility audits; EVV prepayment use; NPIs; 60-day overpayments | Set in final rule | Comment on audit design and the overlap with work-requirement implementation |
| Medicaid managed care plan | 30-day reporting of deaths and address changes | Set in final rule | Test data feeds from vital records and address sources |
| Marketplace agent or broker | New suspension and termination standards; foreign access ban | Set in final rule | Review compliance records and remote access practices |
What to do before the comment deadline
- This week: Confirm the comment date on the published Federal Register page after November 19 and assign one owner per affected program.
- By mid-December: MA plans should run RADV exposure scenarios using the sampling and extrapolation approach in the rule text, and pull a list of network providers without Original Medicare enrollment, which our Medicare risk adjustment guide can help frame.
- By early January: States and managed care plans should document how the new audit and reporting duties interact with community engagement systems and existing PERM corrective action plans.
- By January 19, 2027: Submit comments through docket CMS-2026-0826, with specific data on burden. CMS says it wants comment on the accuracy of its cost estimates, which total about $378.51 million over the same 2027 to 2036 period.
Two things to avoid: do not treat CRUSH provisions as current requirements, and do not cite the $90 billion savings figure as an achieved result.
What to watch next
CRUSH sits alongside other recent CMS integrity actions, including the November 12 six-month extension of the nationwide freeze on new Medicare hospice and home health enrollment. Watch for three things: the published Federal Register version and final comment date, comments from MA plans and states on RADV and eligibility audits, and whether CMS follows through on its plan for annual program-integrity rules.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the CMS CRUSH rule final?
No. CRUSH (CMS-6098-P) is a proposed rule released November 16, 2026. CMS must review public comments and publish a final rule before any provision takes effect.
When are comments due on the CRUSH proposed rule?
CMS’s press release gives January 19, 2027. The rule text sets the deadline at 60 days after Federal Register publication, scheduled for November 19, 2026, so confirm the date on the published version.
Would CRUSH require providers to enroll in Original Medicare to bill Medicare Advantage?
Yes, if finalized. Eligible providers and suppliers billing MA would need approved Original Medicare enrollment, except for PACE plans, starting with the first plan year that begins two years after the final rule.